The University of Iowa College of Dentistry and Dental Clinics logoLink to University of Iowa home pageLink to College of Dentistry and Dental Clinics home page

  college of dentistry mission graphic

Operative Dentistry - Best Practices

Caries Management: Caries Removal - shallow to moderate lesions

(last modified May 10, 2016)

Caries lesion management goals:  based upon symptoms, detection, diagnosis, risk assessment and treatment planning

  • Prevent lesions rather than heal
  • Heal lesions rather than surgically repair
  • Minimally invasive surgical treatment of lesions

Minimally Invasive Surgical Approach    

  • Defect specific lesion access and management
  • Final selection of restorative material after removal of defect
  • Material-specific cavity preparation modifications are then accomplished
    • Repair rather than replace restorations with lesions adjacent to margins whenever possible
    • Restorations are of last resort and do not make patients “caries free”

Caries lesion removal:

(Please see Schwendicke et al. ADR 2016;28:58-67. Managing carious lesions: Consensus recommendations on carious tissue removal.)

  • Convenience form access to the caries defect is made just large enough to sufficiently visualize and adequately instrument the carious tooth structure
  • The caries lesion is removed first peripherally by excavating peripheral 1 to 1.5 mm tooth structure to sound, hard dentin including a visually stain-free DEJ and healthy enamel. Histological “sound” dentin will have similar hardness and texture to sound unaffected dentin when applying a spoon excavator or slowly rotating round bur.
  • Moving inward or centrally from  this hard peripheral region it is acceptable to leave discolored caries affected/reparative dentin that is firm to a hand excavator.
    • Discolored and stained dentin, in itself, does not warrant continued tooth structure removal. Reparative dentin will have a lower hardness and rougher texture as compared to sound unaffected dentin when applying a spoon excavator or slowly rotating round bur.
    • The goal of central (axial and pulpal) caries lesion management is to remove infected dentin only and preserve the pulp; however, with currently existing technologies, clinically removing only infected dentin remains a highly subjective procedure. Therefore selective removal of central dentin should stop when firm dentin is reached.

decision making for noncleansable carious lesions


  • This best practices document does not address alternative caries removal/management strategies, such as, ultraconservative caries removal, indirect pulp capping, stepwise caries removal, etc.
  • Sound dentin has a Knoop hardness of 50 or higher with affected/reparative dentin roughly 25 to 50. This cannot be measured currently in the clinic.